Are French Doors More Secure Than Sliding Doors? A Full Comparison

Key Takeaways

When deciding between french doors and sliding doors, security should be a top priority. Here's what you need to know:

• French doors typically offer superior security when properly installed with multi-point locking systems and reinforced frames

• Sliding doors are vulnerable to lift-and-remove attacks and track manipulation, though modern versions have improved significantly

• Both door types require security upgrades beyond standard factory installations to achieve optimal protection

• French doors provide more locking points (3-5 points vs. 1-2 for sliding doors), making forced entry more difficult

• Your home's security depends on installation quality, hardware choices, and additional security measures you implement

Looking to upgrade your home with secure, elegant door solutions? Explore our premium collection of french doors at Doors and Beyond for options that combine style with robust security features.

 

---

 

Introduction: The Security Question Every Homeowner Should Ask

When you're investing in new doors for your home, the beauty of expansive glass panels and natural light often competes with a more pressing concern: security. I've consulted with dozens of homeowners who love the aesthetic appeal of both french doors and sliding doors but worry about making their homes vulnerable to break-ins.

The question "are french doors more secure than sliding doors" isn't just about comparing two door styles—it's about understanding how each design handles forced entry attempts, what vulnerabilities exist, and how you can enhance protection regardless of which option you choose.

After examining security reports, speaking with locksmiths, and reviewing real break-in scenarios, the answer is nuanced. French doors generally provide better security than sliding doors, but only when installed correctly with appropriate hardware. Let me walk you through everything you need to know to make an informed decision for your home.

Understanding French Door Security Features

French doors consist of two panels that swing open from a central meeting point, creating an elegant entryway that's been popular for centuries. But beyond their classic appearance, these doors have specific security characteristics worth examining.

The Multi-Point Locking Advantage

The most significant security feature of french doors is their multi-point locking system. Unlike a standard door with a single deadbolt, quality french doors secure at multiple points along the door frame:

• Top lock point engages near the header

• Middle lock point (primary deadbolt) secures at handle height

• Bottom lock point anchors the door near the floor

• Additional shoot bolts can extend into the top and bottom of the frame

This distribution of locking points makes it exponentially harder for intruders to force the door open. Even if one lock point is compromised, the others continue to hold the door secure.

Solid Core Construction

Modern french doors designed with security in mind feature solid core construction rather than hollow panels. I recently helped a client replace their 20-year-old hollow-core french doors, and the difference was striking—the new solid doors were nearly twice as heavy and would require significant force to breach.

The frame material matters equally. Steel-reinforced frames provide the best security, followed by solid wood and then composite materials. A strong frame prevents the door from being pried away from the wall, which is a common entry technique.

Astragal Security

The astragal is the vertical piece where both french door panels meet. This component is crucial for security because it prevents someone from creating a gap between the doors. Security-focused french doors use:

• Overlapping astragals that interlock when closed

• Reinforced metal astragals instead of wood or vinyl

• Flush bolts that extend from the inactive door panel into the floor and header

When properly installed, the astragal becomes one of the strongest points of the door system rather than a weak point.

How Sliding Doors Compare in Security

Sliding doors, also called patio doors, operate on a completely different mechanism—one or more panels slide horizontally along a track. This design creates specific security challenges that differ fundamentally from french doors.

The Single-Point Locking Limitation

Most standard sliding doors secure at only one point: a latch that hooks into the frame. This represents a significant security disadvantage. I once spoke with a police officer who explained that burglars often target sliding doors specifically because defeating a single latch takes seconds with the right tools.

Even with a keyed lock, that single point of failure means sliding doors are inherently less secure than multi-point locking systems. If an intruder bypasses or breaks that one lock, the entire door is compromised.

The Lift-and-Remove Vulnerability

Here's a security flaw that surprises many homeowners: older sliding doors can sometimes be lifted off their tracks from the outside. The door sits on rollers in a track, and if there isn't adequate space-filling hardware at the top, an intruder can:

1. Lift the door panel upward

2. Angle it out of the bottom track

3. Remove the entire door from the opening

Modern sliding doors address this with anti-lift devices—small screws or blocks installed in the upper track—but many existing installations lack this crucial feature.

Track Manipulation and Forced Sliding

The track system that allows sliding doors to operate smoothly can also be exploited. Determined intruders have been known to use pry bars to force the door along the track, bending the frame or breaking the latch in the process.

Additionally, the visible track provides information about how the door operates, making it easier to identify potential weaknesses. With french doors, the locking mechanism is less obvious from the outside.

Head-to-Head Security Comparison

Let me break down how these door types compare across the most important security factors:

Locking Mechanisms

French Doors: Multi-point locking systems with 3-5 secure points make forced entry significantly more difficult. The distributed locks mean an intruder would need to defeat multiple barriers simultaneously.

Sliding Doors: Typically feature single-point latches that represent a vulnerability. Even upgraded sliding doors with foot locks or handle locks rarely exceed two locking points.

Winner: French doors provide objectively better locking security through redundancy and distribution.

Resistance to Forced Entry

French Doors: When properly installed with reinforced frames and solid cores, french doors require substantial force to breach. The inward or outward swing means pressure applied to the door pushes against the entire frame and locking system.

Sliding Doors: The horizontal movement and track system create mechanical vulnerabilities. The door can be attacked at the track level, the frame connection, or the single lock point.

Winner: French doors resist forced entry attempts more effectively.

Glass Security

Both door types feature extensive glass panels, which represents a security concern regardless of style. However, there are important differences:

French Doors: Divided light patterns (multiple smaller glass panes) make it harder to create an entry-sized opening by breaking glass. An intruder would need to break multiple panes to gain access.

Sliding Doors: Often feature large, uninterrupted glass panels. Breaking a single large pane can create an immediate entry point.

Both can be upgraded with laminated or tempered security glass, but the divided light advantage gives french doors a slight edge in standard configurations.

Installation Vulnerabilities

French Doors: Require precise installation with proper shimming and anchoring. Poor installation can create gaps that compromise security, but when done correctly, the frame becomes extremely solid.

Sliding Doors: Track alignment and anti-lift device installation are critical. Even small gaps or misalignments can create security vulnerabilities that aren't immediately obvious.

Winner: Both require professional installation, but french doors have fewer moving parts that can be compromised.

Weather Resistance and Seal Integrity

This might seem unrelated to security, but weather stripping and seals that deteriorate create gaps—and gaps compromise security. Over time, I've noticed that:

French Doors: Compression weather stripping can wear but is easily replaced. The door's operation doesn't affect seal integrity.

Sliding Doors: Constant sliding motion wears down seals faster, and track debris can prevent doors from closing completely, leaving small gaps.

Maintaining a tight seal isn't just about energy efficiency—it's about ensuring no gaps exist that could be exploited with pry tools.

How to Make French Doors Secure: Essential Upgrades

Are french doors secure right out of the box? Not always. Even if you choose french doors for their superior security potential, you'll want to implement these enhancements:

Upgrade to Commercial-Grade Locks

The locks that come standard with residential french doors often provide minimal security. Consider upgrading to:

• Commercial-grade deadbolts rated ANSI/BHMA Grade 1

• Smart locks with keypads that eliminate the vulnerability of hidden keys

• Double-cylinder deadbolts for doors with glass within 40 inches of the lock (though check local fire codes first)

I helped a neighbor upgrade their french door locks after a break-in attempt left visible pry marks on their basic hardware. The new commercial-grade system would have withstood that attack completely.

Install Security Hinges

Standard hinges can be removed when the hinge pins are accessible from outside. Security upgrades include:

• Non-removable hinge pins with set screws

• Security studs that interlock even if pins are removed

• Continuous hinges that run the full door height

For outswing french doors where hinges are exposed, this upgrade is absolutely essential.

Reinforce the Strike Plate

The strike plate is where your deadbolt enters the door frame. Standard strike plates attach with short screws that only grip the door jamb—not the structural framing behind it.

Upgrade to a reinforced strike plate that:

• Measures at least 12 inches long

• Attaches with 3-inch screws that penetrate the wall stud

• Features a steel construction box that distributes force

This simple upgrade dramatically increases resistance to kick-in attempts.

Add Security Film or Laminated Glass

Since french doors feature extensive glass, protecting those panels is crucial. Security film creates a flexible barrier that holds glass together even when shattered:

• 4-mil film provides basic protection against accidental breakage

• 8-mil film resists forced entry attempts

• 12-mil film or laminated glass offers maximum security comparable to commercial installations

After installing security film on my own french doors, I tested a sample piece—it's remarkably difficult to penetrate even when the glass underneath is completely shattered.

Install a Security Bar or Door Brace

For french doors that don't see daily use, a removable security bar provides excellent supplemental protection:

The bar wedges against the floor and door handle, making it nearly impossible to force the door open even if locks are defeated. This is particularly effective for securing french doors from inside during nighttime hours.

Consider Smart Home Integration

Modern security systems can integrate with french door sensors that:

• Alert you when doors are opened unexpectedly

• Send notifications if doors are left unsecured

• Allow remote locking verification via smartphone

• Integrate with cameras to record door activity

Important Note: Security technology works best as part of a layered defense strategy, not as a standalone solution.

How to Secure French Doors from Inside: Night-Time Protection

Many homeowners feel most vulnerable at night when they're inside and potentially unaware of intrusion attempts. Here's how to secure french doors from inside for maximum peace of mind:

Deploy Sliding Door Bars (Yes, for French Doors)

Adjustable security bars aren't just for sliding doors. Position one horizontally across both french door panels at handle height. The bar wedges between the doors and adjacent wall, creating a physical barrier that's visible from outside as a deterrent.

Install Interior Deadbolts or Thumb Turns

Double-cylinder deadbolts require keys from both sides, but this can create fire escape issues. A better solution is captive key deadbolts that allow the interior key to be left in place, making exit easy during emergencies while preventing access from outside.

Use Pin Locks at Top and Bottom

Simple pin locks that insert into holes drilled through the meeting stile provide additional securing points:

1. Drill through the active door panel into the inactive panel

2. Insert a pin, dowel, or specialized lock pin

3. The doors cannot separate until the pin is removed

This creates an additional barrier that's only accessible from inside.

Add a Security Chain or Door Guardian

While typically associated with entry doors, heavy-duty security chains or door guardian devices work well on french doors:

They allow you to open the door slightly for ventilation or to check who's outside while maintaining a secure barrier. Choose models rated for exterior doors with substantial mounting hardware.

Motion-Activated Interior Lighting

Strategic interior lighting serves double duty:

• Deterrent effect: Burglars avoid well-lit targets

• Detection benefit: You'll notice movement near french doors

Place motion-activated lights inside rooms with french doors, angled to illuminate the door area without creating annoying false triggers.

Are French Doors Secure Enough for Ground-Floor Installation?

This question comes up constantly, especially from homeowners considering french doors for direct backyard access. The concern is legitimate—ground-floor doors face higher break-in risk than second-story installations.

The answer is yes, french doors are secure for ground-level installation, but only with proper security enhancements. Here's what ground-floor installations require:

A ground-floor french door should never rely on builder-grade hardware alone. Minimum security specifications should include:

• Multi-point locking system with at least three contact points

• Reinforced strike plates with 3-inch mounting screws

• Security hinges with non-removable pins

• Impact-resistant or laminated glass

• Integration with home security system

I recently visited a client whose ground-floor french doors had been installed with all these features. An attempted break-in left tool marks on the frame but failed completely—the intruder gave up and moved on to an easier target.

Consider the sight lines as well. French doors that are visible from the street or neighbor's homes face lower risk because burglars avoid locations where they might be observed. Doors opening to secluded backyards warrant extra security attention.

Real-World Security Considerations Beyond Door Choice

While choosing between french doors and sliding doors matters, professional security experts emphasize that door type represents just one element of home security. Here's the broader context:

Layered Security Approach

The most secure homes use multiple security layers:

• Deterrents: Visible security cameras, alarm system signs, motion lighting

• Detection: Door sensors, glass break detectors, security cameras

• Delay mechanisms: Reinforced doors and frames, security film, upgraded locks

• Response systems: Monitored alarms, smartphone notifications, emergency contacts

Your choice between french doors and sliding doors matters most at the "delay mechanism" layer. French doors with proper upgrades provide better delay capability, giving security systems more time to detect and respond to intrusion attempts.

The Neighborhood Factor

Security needs vary dramatically by location. In low-crime suburban neighborhoods, even sliding doors with basic upgrades may provide adequate security. In areas with higher property crime rates, maximum security measures for french doors become essential.

Check local crime statistics and consult with neighbors about their experiences. This contextual information helps you calibrate your security investment appropriately.

Maintenance and Long-Term Security

Security hardware that isn't maintained eventually fails. Both french doors and sliding doors require regular attention:

Every 6 months:

• Lubricate locks, hinges, and moving parts

• Check weather stripping for gaps or deterioration

• Verify that security screws haven't loosened

• Test smart locks and replace batteries

Annually:

• Inspect frames for wood rot or metal corrosion

• Check that doors still close tightly without gaps

• Verify that security film hasn't degraded

• Test all security features under simulated force

I've seen expensive security upgrades become ineffective simply because lubrication was neglected and locks began sticking, leading homeowners to leave doors unlocked rather than struggle with them.

Modern Innovations Improving Both Door Types

The security landscape for both french doors and sliding doors has improved significantly in recent years. Here are innovations worth knowing about:

Advanced Locking Technology

Multi-point locking systems have become more accessible and are now available as retrofit upgrades for existing doors. These systems allow you to engage multiple lock points with a single key turn, combining security with convenience.

Smart lock integration has evolved beyond simple keypad entry. Current systems offer:

• Temporary access codes for guests or service providers

• Automatic locking when you leave home

• Integration with video doorbells for visual verification

• Lock status monitoring via smartphone apps

Impact-Resistant Glass Standards

Florida's experience with hurricanes has driven development of impact-resistant glass that provides both storm protection and security benefits. This laminated glass features:

• Multiple glass layers bonded with polymer interlayers

• Ability to withstand repeated impact without creating openings

• UV protection that prevents interior fading

• Sound dampening properties

While initially developed for storm protection, these products offer excellent security benefits for both french doors and sliding doors.

Reinforced Frame Systems

Manufacturers now offer door systems with integrated steel reinforcement in both the door panels and frames. These "security-rated" systems undergo testing that simulates real forced-entry attempts, providing verifiable security standards rather than marketing claims.

For homeowners prioritizing security, look for french door systems that meet or exceed forced-entry standards like ASTM F588 (forced entry resistance) or British Standard BS 7950 (enhanced security performance).

Frequently Asked Questions

How secure are french doors compared to solid doors?

French doors with multi-point locking systems and reinforced frames can approach the security of solid doors, but the extensive glass panels remain a vulnerability. The key is upgrading glass to laminated security glass and ensuring frame construction is solid core. A properly secured french door is significantly more secure than a basic hollow-core solid door but won't quite match a steel security door with no glass panels.

Can you make existing french doors more secure without replacement?

Absolutely. You can retrofit existing french doors with security upgrades including reinforced strike plates, commercial-grade locks, security hinges, window film, and supplemental security bars. These upgrades are cost-effective compared to replacement and can dramatically improve security. The exception is if your doors have hollow cores or severely deteriorated frames—replacement may be necessary in those cases.

What's the best way to secure french doors that are rarely used?

For french doors serving as secondary access points, use interior security bars or bolts that prevent opening even if exterior locks are compromised. Install pins through the meeting stiles at top and bottom, and consider a heavy-duty security bar. Since you won't access these doors daily, prioritize maximum security over convenience. Some homeowners even install removable interior panels over rarely-used french doors for complete security.

Are outswing french doors more secure than inswing models?

Outswing doors place hinges on the exterior, which could be a vulnerability if you don't use security hinges with non-removable pins or interlocking features. However, outswing doors have an advantage: you're pushing against the entire frame when forcing them, making kick-in attempts less effective. With proper security hinges, outswing french doors are equally secure and may even resist certain forced entry techniques better than inswing models.

How much should I budget for making french doors secure?

Basic security upgrades (reinforced strike plates, security hinges, upgraded locks) cost $200-500 for DIY installation or $500-1,000 professionally installed. Mid-level security (adding security film, smart locks, multi-point locking retrofit) ranges from $800-2,000. Maximum security with impact-resistant glass replacement, steel-reinforced frames, and complete smart home integration can exceed $3,000-5,000. Start with essential upgrades and add layers based on your security needs and budget.

Do french doors meet insurance requirements for security?

Most homeowner's insurance policies don't specify door types but may offer discounts for security features like multi-point locks, security systems, and impact-resistant glass. Check with your insurance provider—many offer 5-10% discounts when french doors include approved security features. Some policies in high-crime areas may require certain security standards to maintain coverage.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Home

After examining security features, vulnerabilities, and real-world performance, the answer to "are french doors more secure than sliding doors" is clear: french doors provide superior security when properly installed and upgraded.

The multi-point locking advantage, solid construction options, and reinforced frame capabilities make french doors the better choice for security-conscious homeowners. That said, basic french doors without security upgrades won't outperform premium sliding doors with security enhancements.

Your decision should consider:

• Your home's specific security risks based on location and layout

• Whether you'll invest in proper security upgrades beyond basic installation

• The door's visibility and accessibility to potential intruders

• Your budget for both initial installation and security enhancements

Remember that no door is completely burglar-proof—security is about creating enough delay and difficulty that intruders choose easier targets. French doors with multi-point locks, reinforced frames, security glass, and smart monitoring provide formidable barriers that protect your home effectively.

Ready to upgrade to secure, beautiful french doors? Explore our curated french door collection featuring models with advanced security features, multi-point locking systems, and reinforced construction. Each option combines elegant design with the protection your family deserves.